Friday, April 25, 2014

Teaching and reteaching

One of the big criticisms of American education is that the curriculum covers topics, and then goes back and covers them again the next year. I assume the philosophy is that constant revisiting of topics cements them in people’s minds, and shores up any holes people might have. But it can also be mind-numbingly boring. One study I recently came across found that this revisitation might be almost ridiculously widespread.

Some 95 percent of children entering kindergarten can do basic counting and can recognize basic geometric shapes. This is a good thing -- early childhood programs and parents are doing their jobs. Yet kindergarten teachers reported spending nearly 13 days per month working on basic counting and shapes. They spent very few days per month on the topics that children were less proficient in (addition and subtraction, for instance). The more time teachers spent on the basic topics that kids already knew, the more negative were the outcomes on end-of-year kindergarten assessments.

Boredom isn’t good. Being bored is part of life to be sure (I wrote this in a hotel room during a conference, taking a break because I was bored with the panels). But constant repetition on things you already know doesn’t make you more confident in a subject. It makes you dislike the subject. This is a shame -- and not just for gifted kids. When 95 percent of kids know something, it’s time to move on.

What do you remember from school being revisited too many times?

6 comments:

Jamie said...

The American Revolution! Again and again and again and again and again and again...

Gary Franczyk said...

And yet when they taught the American Revolution so many times, they never explained the REASON that the taxes were being levied. I only learned that from Khan Academy.

I can't recall how many times Native Americans were covered. Probably half a dozen times.

Nother barb said...

Just goes to show you, history does repeat itself.

nicoleandmaggie said...

The American Revolution? I'm not sure we ever ever got past Ancient Egypt. (I jest-- we always got at least to Ancient Greece... I know so much about ancient mythologies and mummification.) One year we made it through WWII in Western Civ! But mostly it was Egypt, Mesopotamia, Greece, and then maaaaybe Rome.

Victoria said...

Hello! I cannot wait to delve more into the weblog. I am a new follower, and it seems like there are so many amazing posts here. I understand the "American Revolution" point you made... completely. Also, I featured your weblog at mine this week-- http://love5thgrade.blogspot.com/2014/05/jasztals-resource-spotlight-3-more.html

Dinomom said...

I'm interested in the effects of college-level reteaching of subjects covered in high school. If kindergarteners suffer from boredom or detachment while being re-taught what they already knew, why should we invest kid time and parent money in high school coursework? Wouldn't it be best for the kid to skip the AP classes and some or all of high school and attend a college that specializes in teaching college courses to teens?